I've visited late night for drinks at the bar and also had a brunch here. 3.5-4 stars for late night drinks, 4.5 for brunch. Carmella's has a bar and a couple small tables near the entrance, and a dining area/room in the back with a bunch of tables. They stop serving food at some point in the evening (I forgot what time), but keep serving drinks at the bar.
Late night drinks: I had their Whiskey Sour and the Paloma. Both were good, but not life-changing. I liked the Whiskey Sour more. I think the main problem for me was that there were some people being rambunctious next to us, and there was really only bar seating which I'm not extremely comfortable with. The bartender was very nice though!
Brunch: I ordered the Scallops Benedict. Highly recommend!! The scallops were cooked perfectly and were a decent size. They were well seasoned and tasted delicious. If you like scallops, you should definitely try it out! The potatoes that came on the side were also delicious. For my drink I had the Mimosa, which was pretty average. Would pass on a drink for my next visit.