Overall : 3.5 stars for consistent experience with food, nice decor, staff and drinks. I've been coming back over the course of a few years when I'm in the area.
Food: Call me boring, but if I find food that is consistently decent, I prefer to go for the same thing. My usual go-to consists of their "Sandwiches and Burgers" menu. They used to have a lobster grill cheese that was really good. I don't see it on the menu anymore (please bring it back).
Ahi Tuna Club is probably my favourite. I request switching out the sweet pepper relish for spicy mayo. It comes with a side of skinny fries. I've had this countless times and it's mostly really good. Sometimes it's on the fishy side, but that's not always the case.
I can speak to the fish tacos, butcher sandwich (aka beef dip) and burgers as well. They are quite good. The highlights for me with the sandwiches are the ample amount of protein. I'm always full after the meal.
Service:
I've had good experiences with the staff here. If you let them know you're crunched for time at lunch, they usually do their best accommodate your needs. The waitresses are conversational and try to make you feel welcome.
Parking:
Parking is usually ample, but I avoid parking too close to Wal-mart as that side tends to be hectic. Obviously Markville gets really busy on weekends and evenings, so account for that.