If you look at the gelato places on Yelp!, almost all of them get 4 to 5 stars. I suppose that's because ice cream is really good. But I'm giving 4 stars here because ice cream doesn't have to be really overpriced to be really good. Checking the website of Baskin Robbins I see that you can get a three scoop sundae for the same price as the smallest cup of gelato at Amorino. (How small you ask? They give you something very much like a toothpick to eat it with.) The ice cream at BR is probably not as good, but I like it anyway.