Melt is soooo good! The place is always super busy and a little noisy inside, so we usually order our food for carry out. I try to get a different sandwich every time I'm there, but my husband is loyal to his favorite, which is called "the dude abides". His is basically a meatball sandwich with mozzarella sticks and marinara sauce - really good. My favorite that I've ever ordered is called "new bomb turkey" which basically tastes like thanksgiving on a sandwich. Delicious!
I really don't know if you can go wrong with anything here. Everything I've had has been sooo good. I've tasted the Parma, Italy; the cleveland cheese steak; the curry chicken melt; and the peanut butter banana.
The portions are huge, and I usually save the other half of the sandwich for later. If I heat it in the toaster oven, it tastes just as good as the first time. If you live close, I recommend getting carry out so you don't have to wait so long to taste the deliciousness!