I'm never really sure what to think of Joe Mama's. Sometimes I really like it, and sometimes I'm sad I came. The late night menu is much smaller than Fuel and Fuddle and it's not open as late - which might be why it's easier to get a table than Fuel at night.
The wait staff can be kind of rude - once we showed up at 11pm, we were told that we'd be seated at 11:30. They seated us at 11:55pm, and said "the kitchen shuts at midnight. You have to order now."
It's an old school Italian place, with the peeing statues and everything.
Another note: late night dishes don't come with salads, no matter what the menu says!
Don't expect to be amazed, but sometimes, it just hits the spot.