Time to update an old 2012 review. The good news is, 93 check-ins later, Tony's remains a 5 Star part of my/my family's regular rotation. In fact, I'm here with my youngest waiting on pizza for him and a turkey sub for me as I type this out.
For me, the go to's are almost always the pizza and subs. The pies are classics NY thin crust and the subs are still served on bread imported from a bakery in NJ featuring a perfect blend of light crunch on the crust and a soft, chewy interior.
This is quality food served at a fair price and while this location is the one I frequent the most, I've had similarly good food at locations across the area.