Yeah, really a 3.5.
Pluses include having imperial pints (20 oz instead of those wimpy 16 oz), huge seating areas, outside seating and a cool area.
Minuses include the crappy duo singing there playing most definitely non-Irish music (Johnny Cash ring of fire?) and the relatively high price of drinks (I understand it's downtown, maybe I just don't go out enough to know the average drink price down there).
So yeah, alright bar, and I'll be back.