I've literally been coming to the Old Firehall for ice cream and other treats for 5 years now and needless to say, they have tasty but outrageously priced goods. I remember when their prices were much more reasonable, however in the past 2 or so years, business must've gone done because prices have jumped up $1-4 on most treats.
Overall, it's a good location but expensive for sweets that are nothing special.