Vesuvio's has won me back a little since a couple years ago. I think I had a really bad pie and they're not usually that stale and flavourless.
I like Vesuvio's for their take out slices. At $2.50 for a relatively large square it's one of the better values in Toronto and their slices have always been good. They reheat them for you in the oven so expect to wait a couple minutes. It's partially nostalgia talking because their slices remind me very much of 90s mall-era Mrs. Vanelli's pizza. My memory of this is not great but the texture, crust and cheese combination definitely brings back feelings. Though Vesuvio's sauce is much tastier.
I'm happy to live nearby and be able to pop out for a couple slices when I don't feel like cooking or spending a lot on take out. Service at the take out counter is always friendly. I