I have been coming here for about 10 years and it's reliably good. The service is always prompt and the waitresses are nice and helpful, but not in your face, which is what I prefer.
The wedding soup is delicious and the bread sticks are my favorite of anywhere -- crispy on the outside but not hard and smothered in parmasean and butter. All of the pastas are tasty and the portions are very large. My BF wanted penne alla vodka, their vodka sauce is all white but they offered to mix some red in with him since that's what he was craving and everything is made to order.
I had a sausage calzone and WOW - it was HUGE. Easily enough for 5-6 meals for me. It looked like an extra large pizza folded in half! It was really tasty and was just as good for lunch the next day.
It's not "cheap" but you certainly get what you pay for in quality and quantity. Our bill was approximately $40 for two people with an appetizer, sodas and two huge portions of food.