This is a classy looking, intimate diner and smaller than I expected. I'm very grateful that there was no line-up for my first visit during the lunch hour today. A group of six had a reservation which I think was a smart choice. I will admit to feeling annoyed when restaurants don't have their own free parking but if you're willing to walk about 2 blocks from the East, you'll find some like I did.
I struggled to decide what to eat, as many of the menu items are very appealing. Honestly, I would have opted just for an adult milkshake (Kahlua included) as advertised on the board if I didn't think I'd be judged by my lunch partner. I ended up trying the Ahi Tacos and Deep Fried Pickles. I'd never eaten Ahi before and not only that, I'm not a fan of raw fish. The pan seared Ahi walks a fine line, I have come to realize and a few bites were a little too raw for my liking. I retch a little thinking about it but overall, the tacos were very good. I lathered them in the accompanying chili lime aioli. I really liked the Deep Fried Pickles and was happy to share them because they are quite filling. I sampled my friend's fries which were good and because I like cute and novel things, I'd order them for myself the next time just because of the adorable basket they sit in.
I had asked our server if there were any menu items the Diner is known for and he said everything is amazing. Oh, really? I think I'll return and determine that for myself.