Visited Gotham Bagels for the first time this weekend. I immediately liked the New York-deli vibe and the variety of menu choices, which offered everything from bagel sandwiches to vegan cream cheese and prepared deli foods. I ordered the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, topped with avocado and a fried egg. The flavors went really well together, and the cream cheese was delicious. In terms of the actual bagel itself, I wasn't too impressed with the quality/texture-as someone who has had real New York bagels a lot, I went in knowing that these weren't going to be as good-still, bagel was a little hard, and the texture was mildly chewy which I wasn't a fan of. The sandwich was good, and for a local bagel place in Madison that has a cute vibe, I'd go back.