Updating to 4 stars due to consistency in food freshness and quality, even if it is a little heavy. Sometimes you just need a giant plate of cheese, and when you do, head to Giacomo's.
Their alfredo sauce is made to order, every time. And it's really tasty, especially with a little bit of salt-and-pepper added. The garlic and cheese bread appetizer as well as most of the hot sandwiches have an overload of garlic, but in the best way possible. The eggplant parmesan sub, add grilled onions and light on cheese (which is still a ton), is really amazing.
For a healthier option, try the antipasto salad. It's a steal with a lot of food for under seven dollars.
Service is always friendly and good. I love that this place has an authentic small mom-and-pop feel.