I have been going to Lombardinos for almost ten years now several times a season and as other places had come and gone their pasta and steaks have never dissapointed. Regularly changing menu keeps it interesting. Since the Magnus is not as attractive as it once was this is my go-to place for special occasions and visitors.
I would suggest the two half portions of pasta to try out one of the standards and whatever the current special is. The Calamari appetizer is so far better than the standard that I can no longer order it anywhere else without being highly disappointed. The few times I have had room for a bite the deserts have been great. Beware, the after dinner infused drinks can lay you out!
I have not been to Italy but the only place in Madison that even comes close to the authentic, quality cuisine at Lombardinos is the Greenbush, and they are more of a quick bite with a drink kind of place.