In a word: inconsistent. Accepting that it is a chain, and not a local (sea)foodie hangout, it's usually ok. However, I have occasionally been served truly dreadful food here, from soggy fried shrimp to dried out salads. I don't send food back readily, but have had to do it several times at this location (and not at other Slobster's). Very crowded on weekends. Decor updated recently and is attractive. Servers are usually friendly and often knowledgable if not expert. Managers who will keep the kitchen on it's toes are sorely needed. For the quality I consider the chain overpriced, the seafood version of Olive Gardens--if you are going to pop for lobster or wish to impress someone who's over the age of 17, hunt down a better place and make the drive.
BTW: Do not let them seat you near the serving area by the bar--why they even consider that location fit for customers I cannot imagine, and they seat people there even when there is more desirable seating available (and any other seating is preferable).