I feel that the price is a bit on the high side for what you get. You can get better deals on wings pretty much anywhere else (except Buffalo Wild Wings). They have a wide variety of wraps, salads, sandwiches, burgers and other pub fare. They beef up their menu by combining standard recipes with their sauces, but I never really crave any particular dish from the Winking Lizard.
The quality was and has always been consistently good, but not outstanding. Sometimes they'll burn a burger or your wings will come out cold. The place is always clean, the staff is always solid, and they can usually sit you right away.
One thing I love about the downtown location (and most every other Winking Lizard) is that the floorplan is different from any other restaurant (and from every other Lizard as well). Unlike most other buildings that are usually 4-sided, the downtown location floorplan is in the shape of a triangle. I enjoy how the restaurant has several different dining spaces throughout that give it a smaller feel.
The beer selection is outstanding, but the drink prices are also on the high side.