Much better than I expected. Went on a Sunday morning so it was a brunch buffet that I did not partake in, so I only ordered Tomato Basil soup. The soup was good, though serving size was small for the price and it didn't come with bread. My wife got the buffet and really liked it and she snuck me some bread for my soup and that bread was also good.
All in all, for a place founded based on a TV show, it's really pretty decent. However, it's overpriced. As a bonus, the Carlo's Bakery is across the hall.