This Y has got it all.
Clean change rooms, new machines, a pool, a few gyms, courts, a track, babes in lulus and hipster glasses, and several Canadian rock icons (SLOAN dudes work out here).
The negatives are the high amount of greasy dudes in the weight room with fades in their hair. Portuguese, I assume. I don't shower here so I can't comment on how YMCAish it truly is.
Monthly price is like $60/month... or down to $30 if you're a poor son of a bitch.
They also sell Jamaican patties here. Weird.