This place is a solid 4.5 in my book even though I know it has a few locations elsewhere. For beer selection alone, it's one of my favorite places in the city. The pizza is fantastic - besides beer, this is what I believe they're known for. Their dough is delicious... Also the giant pretzel... Again... Delicious dough. They have a great staff whom are all super helpful and friendly. It's also prime location with a nice patio.
Our favorite is a diavolo pizza though we've had some each since we come with friends and eveyone orders different things. They're all good. Besides the pizza, we've gotten the aforementioned pretzle (YUM) and nachos (also yum).
Fun tip: They have happy hour on weekdays I think till 630 or 7, and a few pizzas are heavily discounted and most definitely worth ordering a pizza each so you have plenty of leftovers. The happy hour beer selection or discount isn't that great though but I don't mind that, since the pizza is such a good deal.
The only negative so far is on our last outing there, the dough looked like it hadn't risen properly. This looked to be the case at a few other tables so not sure if it was intentional or what. It's never been like that before.