My girlfriend and I came here for an early dinner before we caught a movie. The atmosphere seemed a little dark and eerie so I wasn't sure what to expect. After sorting through the menu I decided to try the Lamb Shanks. It just seemed fitting in the dungeon-esk setting in which we were dining. I also noticed the bread and honey butter... I love honey butter so I had to get some. It would have been nice if they would have cut the bread for us but instead we were forced to try and saw through this brick ourselves with minimal utensils (the honey butter was quite good though). The lambshank was decent, not the best ever, but good nonetheless. I really liked the mash potatoes that it was served with - kind of heavy - but that's to be expected.
All in all Alton's Kitchen is A-OK. There's definitely potential here but for the cost I doubt I'll be going back for a while.