I was in my wonderful hometown of Cleveland for a conference and took some colleagues here for dinner.
Cons: Our server couldn't describe any of the wines to us and made no effort to find someone who could. I ordered by guessing and ended up with a wine that I recognized from the endcap of my liquor store (in other words, a real cheapie). I ordered the scallops with sweet potato gnocchi (I think it was a special), and while the scallops were good, the gnocchi was very dry & hard to swallow.
Pros: Our server was nice, and we had a couple other very nice people descend upon our wobbly table to fix it and to clear our plates and offer us dessert. The vibe in the place was good, and I loved that they had an old May Co. sign over the bar. Gave me warm childhood fuzzies!
Overall an OK place, but not sure it's worth the price. You're in a fantastic location, Pura Vida, and have the opportunity to impress a lot of out-of-towners. Try a little harder and make Cleveland look like the great place it is!