Growing up in Bay, I went to this neighborhood restaurant for YEARS with my parents. The food is high quality, with up-scale pub fare on the menu. In my opinion, their burgers are some of the best around. Other than that, the menu has a bunch of seafood options including fresh fish from Lake Erie. Their sweet potato fries are delicious as well. I've never had a bad experience here.
Occasionally the wait times can be a litle bit excessive, since they don't have many tables...but hey, what can you do? Its worth the wait!