I went back today!! (Yes, that was me ordering the slices and soup) I am happy to say that I believe Anselmo's has nailed it just about as close as we will probably find in Cleveland..as I'm told the difference in the crust is in the water in NY which I guess there is nothing we can do about!
I had a couple of slices that had been in the case for about a half an hour..and they were good, so I'm assuming when I order it fresh..which for it be like home would be with extra sauce, cheese and oil! lol then I have a feeling that minus the crust issue, this is going to be the most authentic NY style pizza anyone will find here! So congratulations! I'm excited for my kids to try this again. They are very picky having grown up in NY/NJ.
I also had the Chicken noodle soup, which was very tasty..a tad salty, but overall, very good!
Now, like I said, when you start making those Jersey Subs I told you about please holla! lol