Have been here dozens of times, living right near by. The staff are awesome, service is fast and the food is good. My favorite items on the menu are the burrito, burger, wrap and club.
I like that it doesn't have a million TVs and although there is music playing, it's pleasant and not too loud. The surrounding area is definitely going downhill, unless you're an uber yuppy from Liberty Village, I guess, but this bar is more of an exception and provides a nice escape from the growing King West nightmare.
Go to the Old York if you want a conversation in a comfortable and relaxing environment.