More like a 4.5/5
Is the ice cream delicious? Yes. Is it mind blowing? Nope (I'd rather do Sweet Olenka or even SOMA's).
Are the cookies delicious? Yes. Is it mind blowing? Nope (Le Gourmand wins out)
What I don't get about this place is that the wait time is roughly 1 hour long. You can literally just walk 20m north to the original - Bakerbots - and not get stuck in any lineup.