Gelato Simply Italian is a very small gelato shop on Cumberland Street. After walking by it several times, I decided to give it a try.
I tried the mango and the lemon gelato. It was good, but it seems that they make it using a lot of dairy, and personally I think that gelato isn't supposed to have a ton of dairy in it, but it's supposed to be kind of like a sorbet. Either way, it was good. A tad on the expensive side ($5 for a small!) but I guess that's something that comes with the area.