Shelly's is decent, not great, not really even good enough for me to drive out of my way to visit. I got to sample a key lime pie bite and I was disappointed... It just didn't have the flavor and the key lime had a strange stickiness that felt more like it sat out too long than anything else. The whipped topping was more like rubber... Not sure what was going on there.
Second sample was a lemon curd pie bite and it had the same problem as the key lime pie... Both also suffered from a crust that stuck miserably to the paper wrapper.
The lemon bars had good enough flavor but the crust, which was good as well, dominated. It was very thick and made the thin layer of lemon seem even thinner. I enjoyed what essentially became not a lemon bar but a lemon flavored shortbread style crust... But I wished it had really been a lemon bar, switch the thickness of the lemon and the crust and it will be great.
I really wanted to try a petit four, but some local restaurant had apparently claimed them all... Shelly said they would have more later or the next day but based on my samples, I wasn't going out of my way to see...