I have mixed feelings about Creamisty. It's a cool concept as far as how it's crafted, but something just isn't perfect about the business. However, the ice cream is very good, especially if you are into a very rich, creamy treat. Worth a try? Absolutely.
The downside is that you can easily run up a $10+ desert tab if you get creative...and the small size should be a large! Cookie butter was fantastic but a few bites was plenty. I tried the cookies and cream my second time in - with extra cookies - and that combo was a lot lighter than the cookie butter. Pass on the brownie add-in. They claim to be home made, but it tasted like a rock.
Am I obsessed? Naaaaaaa, especially not for the price. But out of the weak ice cream options in Old Town, I think this is the best.