We happened upon Mary Coyle because we were eating across the street and wanted ice cream for dessert...so we jay walked over to MC Ice Cream. I gave Mary Coyle 3 stars for a few reasons.
1.) The ice cream was soft serve (good).
2.) The atmosphere is really old school, makes you think of buddy holly for some reason. (good)
3.) The ice cream (a 1 scoop cup) took about 5 mins to come out. (bad)
4.) We sat outside and they locked the door at 9:45PM -- they close at 10PM -- so we couldn't even go inside to throw our cups away (bad)
5.) None of the employees greeted us when we went in ...not until we were at the counter for 5 mins (bad)