Came in on a rainy afternoon for a late lunch after seeing the glowing reviews here. It was kind of dark inside, and what sounded like Italian Peter Gabriel was playing from the speakers. I imagine they do mostly a takeout/delivery business. It's not set up like your typical pizzeria, as they have a closed kitchen and no pizza by the slice.
I ordered a half meatball hoagie with fries and a can of soda, came in under $10. Portion size was generous; the fries were a whole plate.
Honestly not sure what the fuss is about. Was I able to eat again that day? No. Was it tasty? Sure. But it wasn't anything special. I got the feeling that the meatballs were from a bag, and the French fries were your typical thick cut food service variety. The toasted roll was good, as was the sauce. Overall, I didn't regret eating there, but I won't be making a habit of it.