Don't order anything fried and you'll be ok, especially during lent. Everything from the fryer tastes like fish marinated grease. I don't think they change the oil enough because everything from the fryer tasted burnt even though it wasn't. We've ordered a few times with the same result.
The pizza is consistently good though! They have great soft pretzel sticks and hoagies as well. And, if you drink beer, they are one of the only local places that will deliver beer to your door.