Yummy food and nice atmosphere.
This was our 2nd visit to the Montauk. The ahi guacamole is delicious as well as the deviled eggs. But the main reason we returned was for the Mac and cheese! Our first visit I ordered it with lobster, this time plain, both excellent.
Perfect spot for my macaroni pregnancy cravings :) the only reason I give it 4 starts is because there are several unbelievable 5 star restaurants here I love and this doesn't seem to fall under the same rating, and the drinks all seemed to have more ice than beverage to us.
It is good food and good service, but in my opinion, not amazing food.