This is a "must" try in Madison. They have expanded their selection over the years to include a salad bar and desserts like puppy chow but the mainstay is still their pizza. Lots and Lots of pizza.
My favorites are their spicy taco, Philly cheese steak, and Buffalo chicken pizza. However, if you have the chance to try their Thanksgiving pizza (once a year in November), you must get it. It is like having a Thanksgiving feast on a pizza all at once. Turkey, stuffings, cranberries, green beans, crispy onions....it is AMAZING.
It's open until bar time so if you're jonesing for a drunk meal or just in the area with friends, stop by if you're hungry for pizza. You will not be disappointed!