Absolutely delightful! I've been to Graft once with a friend and came back last night with my boyfriend. We split four small plates, the bread service (small rolls are to die for), and a few glasses of wine for a pretty reasonable price! Our waitress gave good recommendations and every plate was better than the one before. We got the beef tartare, smoked trout rillette, brussels sprouts, and the pappardelle. I did feel that the bottles of wine were unusually overpriced-- most bottles were north of $40, but we got decent reds for $9 a glass. I'd recommend ordering by the glass since there wasn't much of a price difference buying the bottle, plus we each got what we wanted.
I'd think I'd go back again and again for the food alone, but the atmosphere was lovely as well. It wasn't too crowded on a Wednesday night and we sat by the window so we could look at the Capitol. On my last trip to Graft, I sat at the bar-- less romantic, but still lively and energetic. It was a great experience.