I'm giving Catch 2 1/2 stars. Given I live in the area, I was hoping for better, especially for the prices charged.
$16 for a vodka martini to start is high for Toronto. The scallop appetizer was pretty good, but for $14 I expected more than 2 scallops! The clambake for my entree was again, decent, but nothing special nor memorable, which sums up the entire meal. Again, for the prices charged, I would expect a little more "oomph" in the cooking but instead, received food which I would describe as merely a-ok or competent.
Dessert was a disaster. Some chocolate thing-mess which clearly wasn't made inhouse.
The best part of the meal was the service, which was attentive.
I don't plan on making a return visit.