Decided to give Cibo another shot and see if they've worked the kinks out. I think they have -- both the service and food were noticeably better, and the by-the-glass wine selection was a bit improved (but still not much, and is disappointing considering this is called Cibo *Wine Bar*).
That said, the crowd here on a Friday night was super douchey. (Par for the course in Toronto, really, which is possibly the douchiest city in the world.) I'll likely be back but stick to Monday-Wednesday.