I absolutely adore Hemingway's! If you want a cheap meal in a college bar that's bursting at the seams with fond memories, then this is your place. It can get noisy and crowded later on weeknights and on the weekends, but the staff are all very skilled at working with a high noise level and everyone I've encountered has been really chill.
My boyfriend first took me here for late night half price food (9:00pm-mightnight and also available during the lunch hour) right after we began dating, and we've been back at least ten times together since. That's a lot considering the amount of new restaurants we like to try. It was one of his regular spots in college, and I can definitely see why. I love the wood paneled booths and walls and all the framed photos of friends having an epic time here over the years. You can tell it's a well-loved establishment. The food is also fairly decent for a college bar, and at half price time it's a steal. Additionally they offer cheap pitchers of cocktails/beer/shots and a different $2.50 draft beer special every evening, so you can easily have dinner and a drink for under $10 with a tip. Overall Hem's is a solid late-night place if you aren't allergic to undergrads or loud music, and in the winter the cozy atmosphere makes it especially appealing.