I am rating My Sister's Closet based on a recent consignment deal. A couple of months back I signed over a Paper Boy by G1 button front plaid shirt, a tangerine pencil skirt by The Addison Story, and a beautiful 100% cashmere oversized sweater. Considering the quality and condition of these items, I trusted My Sister's Closet to price these items fairly.
Fast forward two months. I called today (as I now live out of state) to if my items sold and how much money I would be receiving. The saleswoman first told me both the Paper Boy shirt and cashmere sweater had sold, then proceeded to tell me I would only be getting a little over $17 for both items.
Hold on. My Sister's Closet gives you either 40% cash or 50% trade for each item sold. So, on average, they sold a nearly new cashmere sweater and a $70 shirt for roughly $21.00. The shirt is more understandable at that price, but $21 is FAR too low of a price for a cashmere sweater that is less than a year old and in near perfect condition. I thought consignment was the way to go when selling pieces such as these, but apparently I was wrong.
To those thinking about handing things over to My Sister's Closet for sale, make sure to assess all other options before going this route.