Update to my experience. I reached out to the owner Anthony and he apologized for his manager and the experience of the meal. Seems like an owner who really cares about his patrons. I can't say enough good about his reaching out to me and the importance of knowing how much he cares for his business! I also never had issues before this with staff or quality and frequent this place almost weekly for years. I love eating local.
Ordered two pieces of cheese pizza slices and paid for four extra toppings each. I just showed the picture to the manager who told me that even though only half the slice had extra cheese and toppings that what did I expect for 45 cents per topping? Also that they have new people working there and that they are told to limit the amount of toppings and put them dead center. The other piece had no meatballs even though we paid for them. Long time customers totally disgusted with her response. Not going back