I'll give you 3 Athenian, especially since I found you while heading up Central today hungry and totally confused.
I'm impressed with the cheap prices, the "Chicago retired cop" ownership and the attention to cleanliness with the establishment.
The lamb was cooked absolutely perfectly and the produce was impressively fresh however the Tzakiki (spell check anyone?) sauce was rather absent and the amount of feta cheese dumped on top was rather absurd, making a very rich gyro experience altogether.
I'd go back, but being that it's so far from home I wouldn't make an un needed trip to dine here.