My stay at Hotel San Carlos was mostly based on price and lack of availability at more well known chains, so I wasn't sure what to expect. I really wasn't impressed and I wouldn't stay there again.
Upon arrival at about 2:35pm, I was told my room wouldn't be ready until 3pm. Nothing like waiting until the last minute to clean it up! I asked for the wifi password and got some work done in the tiny lobby while I waited.
If you're looking for old world charm, this is the place for you. Priding itself on having hosted Marilyn Monroe, and that it is one of the most haunted hotels in America, somehow this hotel wins guests over despite the small old rooms with tiny bathrooms and musty smells.
To be fair, the hotel was a place to lie my head, and I did have a good sleep. However, it wasn't as comfortable a stay as I would have had at a newer hotel. The shower was a tiny stall with a curtain, which wasn't sufficient when the shower head started spraying all over the bathroom due to a slight leak.
I will also say that the rooftop pool was okay. It had a lot of seating and was better than some others in the city.
If you're looking to step back in time, this is the hotel for you!