The only thing I'll say about the calorie count controversy is that just because something is vegan does not mean its healthy. Sugar and oil are vegan.
I give it 4 stars because what I had (chocolate peanut butter cake and chocolate chip cookies) were good, but pretty expensive. Cookies come to about $1 each. That may sound OK, but they're only about the size of an oreo, so to me $5.99 for the box (don't remember if there were 6 or 8, but definitely not more), is pretty high. I can get cookies that are 3x the size at Whole Foods for $1.49 each and less if you buy a package of them. However, they were among the best vegan chocolate chip cookies I've had.
But the chocolate peanut butter cake (NOT the gluten free version) was really good. Again expensive at $6.50, but its big enough for 2 people to share so if you compare it to restaurant dessert prices, its not so bad. But again compared to nicer grocery store prices, its high.
I looked at sandwiches and nothing looked so amazing that I wanted to pay what they were asking to try them.
Would I go back? Sure, but not so often just due to the prices. It would be a treat only.