This is a great example of relativity -- at 2am in Las Vegas, this would be 5 star. At 9pm in NYC, it'd be a 3.5 star (mainly for price). In the day in Las Vegas, this is 4-4.5.
Good pizzas (NY-style thin crust, maybe a bit California-inspired on toppings), accurate estimates for delivery and pickup times, and friendly service. Prices are a bit high ($32 after tax for a loaded 20" pizza; $25 would seem more fair), but not too bad for what you get.