Hard to go wrong with anything you order here. The line can get long during peak times, but don't stray because it goes very fast and is worth the wait. They recently changed their iced tea section and it is sooooo much better now. The pressed farmer sandwich is outstanding as a vegetarian option, and the burger of the week always packs a ton of flavor and variety.
If you like coffee, try the cortadito. It is simply delicious and the presentation makes you feel like you are at a quaint Cuban cafe.
The desserts are to die for, especially the huge cinnamon rolls. The rice pudding is technically considered a "side dish" but it could definitely double as a dessert.
Make a trip to the bathroom to see the unique decor. One bathroom even has recipes written all over the walls in the most tasteful way you could imagine. I am a detail oriented person and Liberty market has so many quirky details that I love discovering!
The parking can be a pain sometimes with all of the recent development in downtown Gilbert, but there is a new garage going up and a little stroll along the historic area isn't so bad.
I take all our out of town guests here to eat, you should too!