It was definitely overhyped by the time I got to try it, so that's probably why I think it's just okay. I was expecting life-changing pizza, but it's just like any other thin crust, NY style pizza.
It's way overpriced! I went with 3 friends and we managed to make it more cost effective by buying one whole pizza and a 2-liter vs. separate slices and separate drinks for all 4 of us. I think that cut $20 off our potential bill haha.
One positive - we went around... 11:30 a.m. (?) so we beat the lunch rush and didn't have to wait in a line. Once we got our pizza, there was a line of at least 20 people long.
I'd rather eat at Wicked Spoon at the Cosmo and get my pizza from NYNY down the strip!