Good beers, gorgeous surroundings, super cool idea (brewery in a church? Neat!), good food.
There are 2 menus for dinner: the pub menu, for eating at the bar, and the fancier dinner menu. Two people before tip easily ran up a $100 bill with an appetizer, two entrees (nice steaks!) and 2 beers each. Worth it for a special night out (anniversary, etc.). The pub menu is also solid and has standard pub fare - sandwiches, fries. I look forward to eating here the next time I visit Pittsburgh!