Went here the other night, and it was ok.
The Mashaba soup was a highlight - very fresh and especially great if you like coriander. I had the vegetarian combo, which was decent overall. I liked that the three different colours of rice were actually distinct from one another in flavour - not just visually. My favourite part of the main plate was actually a kind of onion-type (I think??) salad which I think probably comes on the side of most plates. The rose water pudding is a nice dessert. There is a lot of food, so definitely go hungry.
My dining partner, usually a huge fan of lamb, wasn't super happy with his korma chalaw. And while MY meal was generally ok, this is not my favourite Afghan restaurant in Montreal, so I wouldn't bother going back. I should also note that this place can get ridiculously noisy, which can be a but off-putting if you happen to get squished between rowdy groups...
Ps. Staff is friendly.