We had our anniversary dinner at this place hoping it would bring back culinary memories from our honeymoon in Spain. The service was great as one would expect from a restaurant of this pedigree, the atmosphere lively, the seating packed and somewhat uncomfortable. Most importantly: the food was good, but not great. I had high expectations for their Paella Negra prepared with squid ink, a dish that we tried and loved in Spain, and my expectations were not met by quite a bit (too salty). I think the word Overrated is a fair characterization.