We went here for our annual Christmas Eve dinner out and experienced lovely service. The Arctic Char was wonderful but the Red Snapper was seared and dried out. No sauce and over cooked which made a bland meal. The butter cake was a rich delicious dessert and I'd definitely eat the cake and Arctic Char repeatedly. The worst part was that my husband (consumed the snapper) got food poisoning afterward. We ate all the same things and the only meal we didn't share was our entrees. Christmas Day was pretty miserable for him and I'm disappointed that we will not visit Mastro's again because the service and parts of the meal were great but to serve food that is not fresh is terrible.