I also have no idea why anyone would not like this place. As far as a high end steakhouse, it is not, but it is slightly nicer than your average casino diner. I really like 'Old School' and this place is cool is sparsely decorated. Restrooms are right outside the door so no 1/2 mile hike, which is nice. Beers reasonably/regularly priced. Waitstaff was very attentive (we were there for a Saturday lunch on a holiday weekend).
I went with my partner and two friends and we all got something different and we all found our dishes to be absolutely delicious. So, if you like Chicken Parmesan, Liver and Onions, a Pulled Pork sandwich (OMG great) and Cheeseburgers (we had the Meyer Lansky burger w/ pastrami on it), you cannot go wrong. The only dings I can think of would be more fries (I love fries) and a $2.50 charge if you straight out order your food to go.